Read the Percentage Before Making the Decision
A scorecard can challenge an investment claim without supplying a complete replacement recommendation. SPIVA compares eligible active funds with assigned benchmarks. It does not compare every client's available active fund with every available index fund after account fees, loads, taxes and trading constraints.
Its treatment of merged and liquidated funds helps address survivorship bias. A screen of today's surviving funds answers a different question from an analysis that begins with the funds available at the start of a historical period. Keep that distinction when reproducing a result or discussing it with a client. The scorecard uses Lipper classifications and the larger share class for its count-based calculations.
The unit is a fund in a defined category, not an individual manager, investment firm or investor dollar. Do not describe a fund-count percentage as the proportion of household wealth lost or the chance that a particular advisor's selection will fail. Longer and shorter measurement windows also begin with different populations; they are not a controlled experiment on one unchanged set of managers.
Selected U.S. Equity Results
The following values come from Report 1a, based on absolute returns for periods ending December 31, 2024. They are percentages of beginning-of-period funds classified as non-outperformers, not average shortfalls or shareholder losses. SPIVA treats funds that merged or liquidated as non-outperformers; it does not observe a full-period return shortfall for every such fund. A fund need not have been behind at its exit to receive that treatment.
| Fund category | Comparison index | One year | Five years | Ten years | Fifteen years |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| All domestic | S&P Composite 1500 | 78.65% | 84.69% | 89.70% | 93.23% |
| All large-cap | S&P 500 | 65.24% | 76.26% | 84.34% | 89.50% |
| All mid-cap | S&P MidCap 400 | 62.00% | 80.00% | 77.32% | 87.50% |
| All small-cap | S&P SmallCap 600 | 29.69% | 60.37% | 82.22% | 90.68% |
The report's summary says that seven of 22 equity categories and eleven of sixteen fixed-income categories saw majority active outperformance at the one-year horizon. No category saw majority outperformance over the fifteen-year period. That is a statement about this report's categories and dates. It is not a rule that all bond funds or all active funds underperform by a particular amount.
The selected equity table also disproves a strictly increasing-horizon rule: mid-cap underperformance was 80.00% over five years and 77.32% over ten. Longer periods often show substantial underperformance, but the rate need not increase in every adjacent column. Nor does a longer sample mechanically separate skill from style, luck and benchmark choice.
Explain the Small-Cap Result Without Inventing Attribution
The 29.69% one-year small-cap underperformance rate means that a majority of that category outperformed in 2024. It does not contradict the category's 90.68% fifteen-year underperformance rate. Those are different historical comparisons.
S&P notes the roughly sixteen-percentage-point return gap between the S&P 500 and S&P SmallCap 600 and suggests that opportunities to tilt toward larger companies may have helped. That is relevant benchmark context. It does not establish that every outperforming small-cap fund owed its result entirely to capitalization drift, or that none demonstrated security-selection skill.
Check a particular fund's mandate, holdings, capitalization exposure and suitable comparison before attributing its return. A manager can outperform an assigned category index while taking risks that differ from the client's intended exposure. Equally, a fund can remain within its mandate and outperform for reasons the category summary cannot identify.
Keep Fund Returns and Client Returns Separate
The scorecard's fund returns are net of fund fees but exclude loads. An index is not an investable account with zero implementation cost. A real comparison should include the accessible index vehicle's expenses and trading costs as well as the active fund's share class and any advisory or account charges.
A historical benchmark gap is also not an immediate tax-saving opportunity. For an appreciated taxable holding, selling can consume resources before the replacement begins earning. In a retirement account, a switch may avoid a current shareholder capital-gain tax but can still change exposure, expenses, trading access and service arrangements.
For a simple cost illustration, assume two new investments each start with $10,000 and earn exactly 6% gross in each of ten years. Subtract annual expenses of 1.00% and 0.10% from each year's gross return. Assume no contributions, withdrawals, other costs or taxes. Ending values are $10,000 times 1.05 to the tenth power and $10,000 times 1.059 to the tenth power. This convention isolates a stated fee difference; it is not the return history of funds in the scorecard.
The lower-cost route wins under those equal-gross-return assumptions. Change the higher-cost route's gross return to 7%, and its assumed net return becomes 6%, above the lower-cost route's 5.9%. That counterexample does not prove that an advisor can identify the higher-return manager in advance. It shows why a fee calculation and a prospective selection claim require different evidence.
Persistence Is a Separate Question
SPIVA's underperformance scorecard and its companion persistence research examine different events. A fund can beat a benchmark without being in the top quartile of its peers. Remaining top quartile in every subsequent annual period is also different from ranking highly over one later multi-year period.
Identify the starting cohort, number of subsequent rankings, category and treatment of merged or closed funds before citing persistence. Do not replace those details with a claim that every top-ranked fund has a coin-flip chance. Outcomes differ across cohorts and measurement windows, and later scorecards can differ from the 2024 snapshot.
Before a current recommendation, consult newer reports as well as the historical example here. An annual refresh should replace all affected opening statements, tables, scripts and takeaways together; changing one year's label does not update the underlying population or inference.
The Client Conversation
“Does this mean I should sell every active fund?”
“It gives us a reason to scrutinize the selection and its cost. Let's identify the role of each holding, the alternatives available in your account and the tax cost of changing. Then we can compare keeping it with a feasible replacement. The category percentage does not decide that comparison by itself.”
Key Takeaways
- Match every percentage to its category, benchmark, horizon and historical report.
- Distinguish fund-count underperformance from investor losses and prospective selection probabilities.
- Treat the 2024 small-cap explanation as context, rather than complete causal attribution.
- Compare actual investable alternatives after relevant expenses, taxes and funding costs.
- Read persistence results as separate, explicitly defined events.
- Use newer scorecards before a current decision and keep every article surface consistent.
The Advisor's Edge
The Certified Fund Specialist® (CFS®) program develops fund-analysis and portfolio-construction skills. Applying those skills means distinguishing what a historical study measured from what a client needs to decide. Document the benchmark, selection rationale, accessible alternatives, costs and no-change case before recommending an action.
For a related discussion, see Does Past Performance Predict Future Returns?.
Sources and Notes: S&P Dow Jones Indices, SPIVA U.S. Scorecard Year-End 2024, summary, Report 1a and methodology. This is a historical report analysis, not a current fund ranking. The cost examples are hypothetical and use the stated gross-return-minus-expense convention. Actual taxes, loads, implementation costs and returns differ.